Monthly Archive for "April 2007"



Quackery Baste on 12 Apr 2007

The Art of Scientific Quackery


Image taken from: http://homepage.ntlworld.com/
andrew.lipson/escher/relativity.jpg

If you want to know why science too often goes down the drain, I recommend you check out the BadScience blog written by Dr. B. Goldacre.
Although the content of some posts, like the recent one on the vitamin-guru Matthias Rath, should be sufficiently known to the public, the response quackery science attracts keeps me wonder about the incidence of common sense.

Neuroprotectant & Caloric Restriction & Aging & ROS Baste on 12 Apr 2007

New Potential for Creatine?

Source: Neurobiology of Aging (2007), in press
Article Type: Original Research
Authors: A Bender et al.


Image taken from: http://www.scienceinafrica.co.za/pics/06_2004/brain.jpg

Creatine (an amino acid derivative) is a widely used food supplement due to its putative ergogenic, i.e. exercise capacity enhancing, effect. In terms of exercise performance, a recent review by Paddon-Jones and colleagues (J. Nutr. 134) concludes that creatine is suggested to be of benefit to exercise lasting 30 seconds or less; in contrast, no direct effect of creatine supplementation on muscle protein synthesis has been found. Nonetheless, creatine sales still reached US$ 220 million in 2005.
So whereas creatine might do rather little to improve exercise performance, it still seems to improve health. And not only this, but also survival – at least in mice. Based on previous reports demonstrating protective effects for creatine in models of neurodegeneration, Bender et al. tested the hypothesis whether creatine might also facilitate healthy aging, particularly of the brain, in wild-type mice. In essence, feeding mice a diet containing 1% creatine from 12-month of age onwards, significantly increased both mean and maximum life span in comparison to control mice. Somewhat confirming what was said already above, the creatine-fed mice did not differ in the rotarod and grip strength analyses; however, creatine feeding improved (p<0.05) several markers of memory performance such as object recognition. Also, biomarkers of brain aging due to oxidative stress tended to be lower in the creatine-fed group. Based on gene expression profiling experiments, the authors conclude that creatine not only reversely regulates gene expression altered in aging, but also concordantly affects gene expression as in mice on caloric restriction. Whether this effect of creatine is due to the induction of mild stress like in the case of caloric restriction is unknown. Another potential mechanism of creatine-induced neuroprotection might be the prevention of ROS (recative oxygen species) generation due to enhanced activity of mitochondrial creatine kinase activity, as recently shown by Meyer et al. (JBC 281).
In light of the rather minor safety concerns raised regarding creatine supplementation, it might be worth to further explore the potential of this amino acid derivative to improve healthy aging.